Evaluation and Use of Journal Articles

Why use journal articles?

  • Current up to date information
  • Subject specific forums for discussion

Types of Journals

Popular

Trade

Scholarly

Eye catching, glossy, use of colour
Aimed at non-professionals
Large amounts of advertising
Illustrated
No bibliographies
Staff writers, may be unsigned
Aimed at a specific audience, often business related
Promote new products or techniques
Staff and contributing authors
May have short bibliographies
Some advertising, related areas
Less glossy, less colour
Aimed at researchers and professionals
Information about current research
Contributing authors, often peer reviewed or refereed
Bibliographies
Few advertisements

The Bulletin
Who weekly
Reader’s Digest
New Scientist
Psychology today

Journal of Food and Nutrition
Nature
Ecos


Consider the following when evaluating: PABACCOBI

What is the purpose of the article?
  • To persuade you to a viewpoint?
  • To prove a theory?
  • To inform about new information

Who is the intended audience?
  • General population
  • School children
  • University students
  • Professionals or specialists
  • Scholars or researchers

Is there bias?
  • Conservative/left wing
  • Alternative press
  • Political or action group
  • Sponsored research

Authority of the author
  • Who is the author
  • Is he/she recognised in field
  • What else have they published

Currency of the article
  • Is it up-to-date
  • Timeless
  • Out of date

What is the coverage of the article?
  • Is it a comprehensive summary of the field
  • Partial
  • Overview

How is the article organised?
  • Is it focussed and easy to follow
  • Is the argument clearly presented
  • Is this original research, a review of previous research or informative

Is a bibliography included?
  • Is it easily understood
  • Short or long
  • Primary or secondary sources

Illustrations
  • Do they assist the reader’s understanding
  • Are they relevant to the article

How to find journal articles


Periodicals

Newspapers

Portal

Electric Library
Macquarie Reference Centre
Electric Library
Echo
Education Age
State Library of Victoria
Register as a user of their
Online databases

Library

Current Social Issues
Current Environmental Issues
Internet
Journal websites
Internet Public Library

Newspaper websites
Internet Public Library